Salut Reflections: Westwood, Mignolet and Bramble make for interesting week in Sunderland.

Jake detects thinking
Jake detects thinking


During Martin O’Neill’s final months as SAFC manager, it became increasingly hard to gather and comment on news for a Reflections piece for Salut! Sunderland, writes Stephen Goldsmith. It seems unlikely Di Canio’s reign will be similar. The end of season is generally a bit of a lull for bloggers and writers, who try their best to avoid getting carried away with bogus and erroneous transfer targets. There have been a couple of interesting developments in the last week, though, “that’s for sure” (Bruce: 2009/2010/2011).

Read moreSalut Reflections: Westwood, Mignolet and Bramble make for interesting week in Sunderland.

Bramble and Kilgallon out as Sunderland retained list revealed

Mrs Logic's classic image
Mrs Logic’s classic image

There was no room for Titus Bramble or Matt Kilgallon when Sunderland announced the list of retained players today.

Other out-of-contract players released are Ryan Noble, Adam Reed and Ben Wilson. Danny Rose and Kader Mangane are not included in the retained list having completed their loan periods, though this does not mean SAFC will not seek to keep either or both. We all know what we want in Rose’s case.

Read moreBramble and Kilgallon out as Sunderland retained list revealed

Two hands clapping for Di Canio’s way with school dunces: (1) just desserts

... Jake suspects PDC may have overlooked a change in the law.
… Jake suspects PDC may have overlooked a change in the law.

There has been lots of media coverage of PDC’s stern ways with lack of effort, truancy, inappropriate behaviour out of school and seriously bad marks. We’ve done our share at Salut! Sunderland and this is something Monsieur Salut prepared earlier – namely for his pages at When I said in my most recent piece there that we could expect more of the same to come, I was aware of the anonymous player who’d called in claiming to be suffering from food poisoning before retreating into telephone silence for hours. I was unaware of the Bramble fine for whatever it was he did or didn’t do in training.

But this – and it could become another series – is my way of welcoming at that ESPN site a tougher approach to player power …

Read moreTwo hands clapping for Di Canio’s way with school dunces: (1) just desserts

Sixer’s Swansea Soapbox: dour, dire Sunderland fail to clip Swans’ wings

Malcolm Dawson writes…. After the euphoria of the win over West Ham and subsequent disappointment of the FA Cup exit to Bolton, I was hoping for an eight point return from the next four league games. Well here we are half way through with four points in the bag but last night was no cause for celebration. I am not one to criticise the team vociferously during a match, feeling that negative vibes transmit to the players and do nothing to lift the team, but last night even I was feeling frustrated with the lack of penetration from our boys. The Swans gave us a lesson in how to retain possession and get forward, though to be fair until Bramble’s back got in the way right at the death, I never really thought we’d concede either. It was a night when I could have stayed home with a couple of bottles of Black Sheep and switched over to “Death in Paradise” as the game sought to define my boredom threshold. It doesn’t seem that our regular reporter Pete Sixsmith was too enamoured either. Here is his take on a mediocre night of Premiership football.

The words dour and dire are quite close to each other in my Oxford Compact Dictionary.

They were a lot closer after last night’s extravaganza at the Stadium of Light.

Let’s deal with the dour first, because that is where we take any positives from and goodness knows we need to look for some. So, take a bow John O’Shea and Titus Bramble who held the centre of our defence together and stopped Swansea from taking advantage of our feeble efforts in midfield and up front.

Both players were mightily impressive in thwarting the Swans. Both read the game really well, with astute interceptions and powerful headers. It wasn’t until the last few minutes that their resolve cracked and Swansea were able to create a couple of good chances – one of which should have been converted. Thanks for that Alex Dyer.

But it made for dour stuff as we defended for the majority of the game. Fletcher worked very hard up front and Sessegnon sparkled for twenty minutes or so at the start of the second half, but we were somewhat lacking in the imagination department for most of the ninety minutes.

I’m afraid the dire takes up more room than the dour. The OCD define it as ‘calamitous, dreadful, ominous’ and, as a British colloquialism for ‘very bad’. It’s perhaps a little harsh to describe the whole performance in these terms, but there were elements of it that we deserved.

Bramble proved to be an  impenetrable barrier
Bramble proved to be an impenetrable barrier

Our midfield was as weak as it has been all season and never once got to grips with the far slicker passing style that Michael Laudrup has brought to South Wales. N’Diaye looked like a little boy lost as Swansea simply passed the ball around him. It got to the stage where it looked like a training routine where the ball had to be kept away from the prospective tackler or, as the man behind me said, “Looks like the game I play with my Jack Russell where I just roll the ball around and he chases it. Never caught it yet”.

Both he and Vaughan struggled to get into the game in the second half, and Vaughan was put into his least favourite position of turning with the ball as Swansea worked him out. He gave it away twice in dangerous areas, almost causing a goal on one occasion and looking more of a liability than an asset.

Consequently, all we could do was lump the ball up front and the fluency and fluidity that we showed against Wigan and West Ham was conspicuous by its absence. We find it very difficult to create against a crowded midfield and give possession away far too cheaply. Against some sides you get it back quickly, but not against a side like Swansea, whose football culture is dedicated to retaining the ball and using it.

In fact, it wasn’t a very enjoyable night at all. The crowd was a respectable size but was not particularly encouraging. There is a feeling amongst many of us that this isn’t why we come to football to watch a goalless draw in which we fail to have one serious goal attempt in ninety minutes.

The effort the players put in is appreciated, but the lack of an incisive final ball is a real worry for those of us who remember the likes of George Herd, Ian Porterfield, Tony Towers, Paul Bracewell, Lee Clarke, Claudio Reyna – all players who could open up a tight defence and find that one telling pass that leads to a goal opportunity.

And then, we have the South Stand, the self-styled singing area. At its best, as against West Ham and Manchester City, it creates an atmosphere which we more restrained types will pick up and turn into a scaled down Roker Roar. At its worst, it can be an embarrassment.

Last night was one of those. A song about the infamous Swansea ball boy included a word that is offensive to all female supporters and most male ones. The song about Danny Graham sung by enough that it would be audible to him, was downright stupid.

Here we are, struggling to score goals and on the verge of signing a young man who has shown that he knows how to do it, and he is described as ‘scum’ by a vociferous minority. Maybe the financial recompense will be sufficient for him to shrug it off, but if he has any second thoughts about the move, fails to complete it and then Steven Fletcher tears his ligaments on Saturday, we can point the finger at those ‘supporters’ who may have discouraged him.

If a player is good enough, it doesn’t matter who he supported as a boy or who he supports now. That player is a professional who should be quite capable of playing well and scoring against the team he loves. It never stopped Mick Harford from banging them in against us and I am sure that the game is littered with players who have scored against the team they have supported since they were toddlers.

Finally, what about Swansea City? Lovely team to watch, far more incisive than last season and looking like a team that is settled into Premier League football. They will do very well to retain Michael Laudrup in the near future if he is desperately ambitious, but he is a far better manager and personality than Brendan Rogers. Michu was quiet but looked quality and I really liked Ben Davies, particularly when he went forward.

Chico Flores is a good centre half but his histrionics spoiled a good performance. O’Shea had a not very quiet word with him when he went down on his knees in our box in the first half and his rolling around in his own box in the second half would have graced, er, a Swansea ball boy.

Two contrasting views on management; prosaic from Martin O’Neill, expansive from Michael Laudrup. By 9.30 last night I know which one I would have preferred.

Salut! Reflections: Fletcher for Scotland, Bramble’s form and Villa’s Darren bloody Bent

Stephen Goldsmith ponders Fletcher, Bramble and Bent

Stephen Goldsmith writes: I can’t believe I’m about to venture into Darren Bent territory once more. Well actually, I can. He simply doesn’t make it easy for us Sunderland fans not to. There are two developments directly involving Sunderland to discuss on Salut! Reflections this week, with Darren Bent being another. Let’s get to it…

Read moreSalut! Reflections: Fletcher for Scotland, Bramble’s form and Villa’s Darren bloody Bent

Bruce spot-on with Bramble; Bardsley needs a rocket too

Is it a breach of Salut! Sunderland‘s policy of getting fully behind the Lads before matchday to support Steve Bruce’s comments on the Titus Bramble affair? I don’t think so.

Bramble has been suspended pending a club investigation into those aspects of the early-hours Yarm incident that concern club discipline. He therefore plays no part in the approach to West Brom at home tomorrow.

Read moreBruce spot-on with Bramble; Bardsley needs a rocket too

Just when we thought it couldn’t get worse: part 2

From our friend Addick-tedKev

Thanks heavens for the principle of Innocent Until Proved Guilty.

When Sky Sport quotes Cleveland Police as saying “a 30-year-old man has been arrested on suspicion of sexual assault and possession of a Class A drug”, that 30-year-old male is Titus Bramble.

Read moreJust when we thought it couldn’t get worse: part 2

How Ashley Cole, Wayne Rooney and £££££ threaten football passion

Two comments at the Blackcats list, admittedly posted after the awful defeat at Everton, raised some gloomy thoughts about the state of football, and our relationship, as supporters, with the game.

The exchange covered cheating, money, arrogance, role models and recent controversies concerning Ashley Cole and Wayne Rooney.

Read moreHow Ashley Cole, Wayne Rooney and £££££ threaten football passion

Niall Quinn, Titus Bramble and presumptions of innocence

Click here and you will quickly see what you are invited to sign. Most of us pay lip service to notions of justice. In practice, we repeatedly encounter anomalies …

Niall Quinn stands convicted on one count – not knowing the difference between refute and deny – but is absolutely right to put out a dignified club statement* emphasising that Titus Bramble, arrested on suspicion of rape, maintains his innocence.

Niall was also wise enough to the potential charge of hypocrisy to avoid adding that whenever an individual is charged with a crime in the UK, and indeed his own native Irish Republic, there is – notionally at least – a presumption of innocence. It is nevertheless worth pointing it out: Bramble has not even been charged; if and when that occurs, he must be seen as innocent until and unless found guilty.

Read moreNiall Quinn, Titus Bramble and presumptions of innocence

The Wigan Athletic ‘Who Are You?’

It could be subtitled “and how Sunderland missed out on N’Zogbia” – read on for a fascinating account of the aborted deal. We’ve said it before, or something like it. If Bernard Ramsdale* didn’t exist as an outstanding example of the (proper) Lancashire football supporter, he’d need to be invented. A past winner of our annual Who Are You? awards, he returns from a little rest – from Salut! Sunderland duties but not much else – with some more pearls ahead of Wigan v SAFC on Saturday. Bernard, landlord of Ye Olde Tree and Crown fan site, has tremendous humour and a refreshingly down-to-earth outlook. It really is a great read. But don’t expect a non-stop bundle of laughs; Bernard lives with the distressing consequences of an awful family tragedy …

Read moreThe Wigan Athletic ‘Who Are You?’