Tony Gallagher, Daily Telegraph editor, on his beloved West Ham

This week’s “Who are You?” feature – ahead of Sunderland v West Ham tomorrow (fingers crossed) – richly deserved another outing, in modified form, especially after the distractions of Zurich.

Tony Gallagher*, editor of The Daily Telegraph and Hammers fan par excellence, probably said more to Salut! Sunderland about his footballing passion, and indeed about himself, than he has done in any other public forum in his life. Or so we’ve heard it said. We are delighted he gave such time and energy to the exercise. Go back to Thursday’s original appearance of the interview to see the comments already posted by SAFC and Hammers fans (and Tony himself, in response to points made), or start afresh here.

By way of reminder: even before he became the editor of Telegraph, Tony had made his mark as deputy editor (effectively running the paper in the long absence on other business of the then editor Will Lewis, another Hammer). It was on Tony’s watch that the paper revealed the scandal of MPs’ expenses, and he is credited with masterminding the coverage. At a guess, he is not on the Christmas card list of the former Labour MP David Chaytor, pictured above, now in a spot of bother as a result.

Some MPs, it is fair to say, had visions of pots, kettles and a very dark colour at the thought of journalists lecturing anyone about expenses. But that’s another matter, as is Tony’s lifelong support for West Ham United. Sunderland fans have been jittery all week, some even hoping for a postponement; we’re glad to say Tony takes a gloomy view of his club, too, despite impressive wins over Wigan and Manchester United …

Salut! Sunderland: (Before this mini-revival), a Hammers-supporting pal declared himself lost for words. What the devil went wrong, and did you not share the excitement of some fans when Sullivan/Gold moved in?

Notwithstanding our amazing result against Man United, we’re paying the price for undermining a series of decent managers. Pardew was sacked peremptorily a few months after taking us to the FA Cup final; Curbishley steered us to mid-table safety and then he was sacrificed; Zola was obviously an outstanding coach – it was no accident that Carlton Cole, Scott Parker and Robert Green were playing the best football of their careers under him – but he was destabilised the moment Gold and Sullivan arrived and never recovered. Grant, demonstrably, lacks the motivational powers required to effect a change.
The Sullivan/Gold era has been pock-marked by one ugly dispute in the press after another which is extremely undignified. Personally, I have never warmed to them, assuming their passion is really for the Olympic Stadium, which I guess would generate huge revenue.

Yet you turned us over at the Stadium of Light, in a cup our fans desperately wanted us to do well in, and clearly have some high-class players. Can you dig a way out of it, and would that require a change of manager?

I still foresee relegation unless there is a change of manager soon. They need someone with better motivational powers and a proven track record. Martin O’Neill springs to mind as a manager who may, just, fancy the challenge.

What were your minimum and maximum expectations when the season started?

I predicted a long, hard season, to be candid, but I hoped we might avoid relegation. The new arrivals like Barrera and Hitzlsperger seem like medium-class makeweights and, Obinna and Piquionne excepted, have not done enough to supplement a team that barely escaped relegation last time.
However, I have been delighted to see the consistently outstanding form of Scott Parker, still mysteriously overlooked by England, who is one of the few players to emerge with credit thus far this season. Green, despite his World Cup horror show, has also been excellent.
Our central defence is an awful worry. Upson cannot seem to find consistency and is paired with a different player every week. We’ve played without a proper right back for two seasons since the departure of Lucas Neil – hardly great planning.

What have been the highs and other lows of supporting West Ham (but please be too young to remember WHU 8 SAFC 0)?

Not too many highs on the horizon of late though I have a special memory of the 85-6 season when we put 8 goals past Newcastle – the only time my then wife-to-be has ever attended a game. It was also our highest ever finish in the division and we were in contention for the title until the final days.
My personal low was the two seasons we spent in the Championship from 2003. We were relegated with a side that included Joe Cole, Trevor Sinclair, Paolo Di Canio, Freddie Kanoute, Michael Carrick Jermaine Defoe and Glen Johnson.
Bad as that was – most of the above left us instantly – the following two seasons were awful. I have an especially grim memory of seeing Rotherham defeat us at Upton Park. Brighton too. The quality of the football was appalling and I couldn’t wait for promotion. When we finally escaped, by the skin of our teeth via a playoff, I felt as though I had escaped a high speed car crash.
I loved most of the subsequent Pardew era and especially the run to the FA Cup Final when the Gerrard wonder goal condemned us to a penalty shoot out defeat.

Who are the greatest players you have seen in your club’s colours, and who should have been allowed nowhere near them?

My personal favourite is Bobby Moore though honourable mentions must go to Billy Bonds, Alvin Martin, Alan Devonshire, Frank McAvennie and Tony Cottee. More recently, we enjoyed John Hartson in a golden spell, Eyal Berkovic was wonderful and Yossi Benayoun springs to mind. Di Canio was always great if a little mad. Joe Cole, sadly, needed to leave to realise his potential, though he has never quite reached the stratospheric heights I anticipated when I saw him win an FA Cup youth final.
The worst? A very long list, most of whom figured under Harry Redknapp. We bought a striker called Marco Boogers who endured a breakdown after figuring for just a few games and was last heard of living in a caravan. We also bought the appalling Romanians, Ilie Dumitrescu and Florin Radicoiu, after they played brilliantly in the ’94 world cup. I recall Florin preferred to go shopping at Harvey Nichols rather than face Scunthorpe in the League Cup.
Gary Duffy was another dreadful low point. I remember him turning his back on a Man U goal when we lost 6-0 and he rarely figured after that. He was an appalling excuse for a centre half.

Any thought on Sunderland, or the people who have been associated with both clubs: eg Pop Robson, Don Hutchison, Anton Ferdinand, George McCartney (a total flop when he came back to us), maybe others I’ve overlooked?

You were miles better than us when we met in April although we managed to eke out a nervy 1-0 victory.

Hutchison was a poor performer for most of his career with us. Anton was always good, though he seemed to fall out of favour at the very end of the Curbishley regime and was sacrificed for cash. He was always excellent, if in the shadow of his brother.
The same happened with McCartney, who was absolutely terrific for us and has never been adequately replaced. Sorry to hear he’s been a flop.
You look like a decent side this season, well set up and hard to beat. I loved Gyan in the world cup and he looks a good if expensive signing. Bent is always a danger and Henderson is obviously a great find. I always like Kieran Richardson but he has never lived up to his initial promise for me. Welbeck is a fantastic loan signing from what I have seen.

Have you already forgotten the World Cup or can’t you wait for the next one?

England were awful but I loved the World Cup and was delighted Spain won. I attended their semi final and was thrilled the best team in the tournament triumphed, especially with players like Xavi and Iniesta. I am already making sneaky plans for Brazil but will try to avoid watching our serial-underachievers if I’m lucky enough to go.

Is it time to abandon high-minded principles of fair play and accept that cheating – diving, feigning injury, trying to get other players booked or sent off – is part of the modern game? if not, how do we begin to stamp it out?

Video, video, video. I am 100 per cent in favour of managers having, say, two challenges per half to overturn dud decisions. Sky has made the referee’s job almost impossible and, without video, we will always have bonkers decisions. A balloon-aided goal anyone?

Name this season’s top four in order and the bottom three. If our clubs are not mentioned in either list, where will they end up come May?

Manchester United, despite their blip against us, will be the team to beat. Chelsea, for all Ancelotti’s genius, look old. Arsenal. Man City.
I fear it could be the 3 Ws heading down: West Ham, Wolves and Wigan. We beat Wigan 3-1 on Saturday and, while it could turn out to be a turning point, they were truly gruesome throughout so it’s hard to judge.
You will secure a very respectable mid-table finish at least after a good FA cup run.

And if it came to the worst, would the Hammers do a Newcastle or take longer tor recover?

I think the Championship is incredibly competitive and any one of 10 teams are capable of going up. I think we have the fanbase to make us short price favourites but there are no guarantees and you can easily go bust if your club is not well run. For every team that comes straight back up, there’s a Leeds, Sheff Weds or Notts Forest that seem doomed to a twilight zone.

Do you want your club to move to the Olympic stadium?

No. We don’t have 50,000 fans to fill it and I will be miles from the pitch but, as I said, I suspect the owners think it is a fantastic money-making opportunity.

What will be the score in our game and how, if not there, will you keep in touch with it?

A nervy 1-1 draw, assuming we take the lead. If you score first, I would see us folding quickly. I will be following it via BlackBerry or, if very lucky, via a dodgy pub satellite.

* Tony Gallagher on Tony Gallagher:: I blame my father for West Ham. He worked in the East End so it became my club of choice. Now that I have children, I have passed the affliction to them, using the Jesuit principle of indoctrinating them young – important in an area where Arsenal dominate kids’ habits. My son Conal went to his first game at six months in a baby sling – a 2-2 draw with Man U and my daughters Catriona and Maeve both go occasionally.

Interview: Colin Randall, who adds:

** not really an interest to declare but I worked for the DT for 29 years. I left – that’s a euphemism – before Tony arrived.

See also: The Press We Deserve? : The Daily Telegraph

*** the Salut! headline writer has been sacked for his earlier Telegaph gaffe.