Hutch’s Patch: Fletch and Réveillère star in one-word Sunderland performance assessments

Jake: Rob's ratings
Jake: Rob’s ratings

Monsieur Salut: writes: Opinions. We’ve all got them. Nic Wiseman and I have been debating at twitter on the Palace goal. Was it a world-class save by Pantilimon undone by the rebound off Wes Brown, as he believes, or two-thirds of a great save which ended with a fumble, as I wrote – on the strength of a single view from the stand – at ESPN? Rob Hutchison was there, too, and among his one-word, pre-Keir snap judgements, our big Romanian scored 7. I’d have made that a 6 and Brown a 7 but otherwise concur with Rob …

Read more

Sixer Says: beginning of the end if we lose this one?

Jake: 'this time, Lads?'
Jake: ‘this time, Lads?’

Pete Sixsmith is a worried man and he knows other worried men. It is up to Gus and the Lads to ease his concerns, starting at Selhurst Park …


We all accept
that Monday night brings a crucial game for both Sunderland and Crystal Palace. Win it and we rise above Palace, Leicester City and a plummeting Aston Villa and we will be on the same points as Hull City.

A draw keeps us in the bottom three but halts the mini-slump that has hit us in the latter days of October.
Lose and Palace will be four points ahead of us and Neil Warnock will be gloating – and we don’t want that do we, boys and girls.

Read more

Crystal Palace vs SAFC ‘Who are You?’: on recovering from Liverpool’s nine

Jake has ways of making them talk
Jake has ways of making them talk

The Eagles Beak* is a fine Crystal Palace fan site, not infallible on apostrophes as you can see but a place accommodating enough to allow Pete Sixsmith to ramble on about why he dislikes Palace. It was created and is edited by Jay Crame*, who joins us now for the latest edition of ‘Who are You?’. He tries to make us feel better about that mauling at St Mary’s..

Jake: 'this time, Lads?'
Jake: ‘this time, Lads?’

Read more

Crystal Palace vs Sunderland ‘Guess the Score’: redemption time?

Jake's new Guess the Score image,  with the usual insolent caption
Jake: ‘you can get your own After Eights this week’

The rollover Guess the Score competition for Sunderland vs Arsenal was won by our resident harbinger of doom, Bill Cowell.

The man will soon run out of space for all his prize mugs. Two more are on their way from Personalised Football Gifts, to be preceded or followed by a carefully packed box of After Eight mint chocs, for which Pete Sixsmith dug deep into his pockets to stump up the purchase price, Nestlé having been too humourless to do so itself.

Jake: 'this time, Lads?'
Jake: ‘this time, Lads?’

Read more

Cabral: curious case of CL player begging to ‘train with the kids’

Another of Jake's new images.
Jake: ‘Cabral? Yeah, I remember him’

Cabral’s acquisition was one even Paolo Di Canio was thrilled by. A player of Champions League pedigree, he played well when given early spells of action but was abruptly dropped. Then he may as well have disappeared from Wearside, never to return. Now, Gus Poyet has made some utterly mystifying comments of his own without getting close to explaining why Cabral cannot get into a team he claims to have to pick from threadbare resources. Can Pete Sixsmith get to the bottom of it? …

Read more

Another view of SAFC vs Arsenal: a defence of Buckley

Jake says "It's gonna be a long hard season!"
Jake says “It’s gonna be a long hard season!”

Monsieur Salut says: it is said few people witnessing the same event, be it a car crash or a football game, see it quite the same way. For the definitive assessment, go to deputy editor Malcolm Dawson’s report. I felt Jack Rodwell, Seb Larsson and Adam Johnson had reasonable games – no more than that, though – and that it was an error on Gus Poyet’s part to substitute the first and third of those. Young Keir Bradwell agreed with me on Johnson and Rodwell but was harsher on Larsson, where he found common cause with a new guest contributor, Simon Ramsey. Against the more common view, Simon found kind words for Will Buckley. A home and away fan for 30 years and a regular supporter of Salut! Sunderland at Twitter, Simon offers his thoughts here for the first time …

Read more

Keir’s Player ratings: Rodwell, Johnson and PVA best of a poor bunch

Keir Bradwell
Keir Bradwell

Monsieur Salut writes: Keir Bradwell‘s “after Len Shackleton” device for his ratings from Southampton – a blank page – divided opinion. This week normal business is restored. I would not quarrel with most of it, save that Larsson’s industry merited a high mark and Wickham was, in truth, no better served than Fletcher …

Read more

Pure Poyetry after Arsenal: Sunderland so difficult to beat they’ll do it for you!

Malcolm Dawson writes…..it’s part of the manager’s job to be upbeat and seek out the positives. He couldn’t quite do that last week but is back in the groove after two of the most schoolboyish of errors cost the team a point and bit more composure should have seen the Gunners punished for their own keeper’s howler. Were there any positives? Gus thinks so as his post match e-mail explains. You’ll get my views tomorrow as I fill in on Pete Sixsmith’s soapbox.

Jake sees Poyet's point
Jake sees Poyet’s point

Read more