Roy Keane and the great transfers debate (1)


For most Sunderland fans, I imagine, Roy Keane will have struck exactly the right tone with his comments about our modest returns – so far – in the transfer market.

Read the quotes for yourself, but he urged impatient supporters to “chill out and relax”, spoke of ongoing negotiations to bring in more people, including names to excite the fans, and suggested that despite disappointment that the David Nugent bid led nowhere, anyone thinking SAFC was “hanging our hat on him” was sorely mistaken.

Keano’s reassurance adds to the debate raging wherever Sunderland fans meet, face to face on via the internet. I have asked two contributors to the Blackcats discussion group to repeat or expand on views expressed there for the benefit of Salut! Sunderland readers (of whom there have been more than ever over the past 24 hours – shows what a reference on the mighty Ready to Go SMB forum can do).

In the first, and all the way from his American home, Mark Hanson* delivers a kick up the collective backside of moaners (I was among those he listed, though I think I have been even-handed in my comments to date).

Click for the continuation page to read Mark’s views:

Read more

Don’t know much about geography



Picture: DarlaMack

The little Salut! empire is playing around with geography. It always fascinates me to look behind the scenes of my StatCounter register and see where my readers come from.

Some obviously arrive by accident and waste no time in speeding off into the sunset again. But others, wherever they start their cyber journey, land on this site because they are looking for something. I hope they find it here, just as I hope some of the casuals stick around, pleasantly surprised.

Now you can share my perusal of the origins of all those who are joining you day by day in reading about Sunderland AFC. It’s down at the bottom of the right hand column.

Read more

Messed around kickoff times



Picture: bods

If there is anything more ridiculous than the FA being able to bully, sorry persuade, tinpot little fanzines and fans’ sites into not publishing fixtures lists without first paying a fee, it must be the fact that these lists are worthless in any case.

Remember thinking that we would start our Premiership campaign against Spurs at 3pm on Saturday August 11? And that we then played Birmingham on Tues Aug 14?

Wrong. The opening game has been changed to suit telly and will now be played at 12.45pm – and to hell with the fans if they find the switch makes travel plans difficult or even impossible.

And Ian Todd at the London and Southern England branch has just pointed out that as a result of Birmingham’s opening game being moved to the Sunday, their next, against us, will now be
a day later, on Wed Aug 15.

Read more

Higher hopes

At some stage I shall get really worried about the level at which our actual or suspected targets have been playing their football.

For now, it being early July, I prefer to remain upbeat. I cling to the belief that Roy Keane et al know what they are doing, have found gems in the Football League and Scotland and will one day soon land a couple of bigger fishes.

What of those who have eluded our line and hook?

David Nugent, so a Preston fan tells me, chose the unusual forum of a chance nightclub conversation to announce that he would be signing for Portsmouth tomorrow (Monday).

We’ll know soon enough about that. And I have not forgotten the views of those SAFC fans who said our failure to get him was really no great loss. My PNE man naturally thinks otherwise, though he admits that Nugent is the sort of player that “needs someone else alongside him” if he is to score a lot of goals.

But what interested me more was the player’s reported response when, in the same snatched nigthclub chat, he was asked what had gone wrong with the Sunderland approach.

“Roy Keane wanted me to sign there and then,” he supposedly replied.

Interpret those words. He meant:

1) I was hoping to use SAFC’s bid to coax my cherished Everton into coming for me
2) I wanted to use SAFC’s bid to encourage someone else to come and offer a better pay deal
3) I don’t actually fancy living in the North East
4) I wasn’t sure that I didn’t want to stay at Preston and help get them up next season

Read more

Wages of sin: pay inflation sharpens Keano’s transfer challenge

So David Nugent will not be playing in the new Boylesports-sponsored red and white stripes of Sunderland in the coming season, and our post-promotion list of acquisitions stands at two*: the encouraging purchases of Greg Halford from Reading and Russell Anderson from Aberdeen.

Very little of what I have seen or read about Mr Nugent inspired me to think that here was a top class striker who, despite showing a lack of obvious enthusiasm for a move to the Stadium of Light, would quickly win a place in the hearts of our fans.

Niall Quinn, I am sure, was right to express some understanding of the reasons for his prevarication. Roy Keane was even more right to become exasperated enough to conclude that he had no further interest in the player.

The Sportingo fans’ site was probably being a little harsh on Nugent in suggesting that he has been less than gentlemanly in his dealings with SAFC.

But from Sportingo’s assessment of him as a “rather limited player” to Terry McLoughlin’s view, at the Blackcats loop that he is “an unproven, average-to-decent, Coca Cola striker”, there seems little cause to be weeping into our beer (or vin rouge).

It is also far too early to become despondent about our slow progress in the business of strengthening the squad.

While we were all still reflecting on a great promotion season, Keane, Quinn and the chief executive Peter Walker were busy hammering out a wish list of nine targets. Not all of these even figure in the mile-long “rumour mill” list at the official club site and there is every reason to believe we will still land some of them.

Read more

Tasmin Archer’s everyday story of Sunderland-supporting folk

TasminWho said the Celebrity Supporters series was a one-hit wonder? No sooner had we finished the task of painstakingly typing out the last of the old interviews, which had somehow fallen off everyone’s computers, than new subjects came into view.

Tasmin Archer, who had a number one hit with Sleeping Satellite in 1992 and collected a Brit award the following year, was one of them. Great minds thinking alike, my approach to her came just as one Salut! Sunderland reader, Pete – another Pete, not the Sixer’s Sevens Pete – suggested her among a list of stars who had expressed some attachment to SAFC.

She agreed like a shot, and proved to be a terrific interviewee, plainly as passionate about the Lads as she is about her music.

The one question that had her not so much struggling to answer as struggling to be unequivocal was the obvious one: what feels better, getting to No 1 in the charts or seeing Sunderland clinch promotion/championship?

Read more

Fixtures and fittings: fixing and fitting them to Mr Murdoch’s taste)

Keano2
So, then. A point at home to Arsenal on Sunday May 11 2008 and the championship should be ours.

Ok, we may also need to pick up a few points before then, starting with the opening game, against Arsenal’s north London rivals Tottenham and also at home, on August 11.

I am indebted to Mark Walton over at the Blackcats forum for the 2007-2008 list, which I discuss on the continuation page and can also be seen in full here.

But if you live a long way from Sunderland, or from the venue of that away game you’ve set your heart on attending, do not overlook the Murdoch factor. Think hard, therefore, before committing yourself to that EasyJet flight, cheap advance rail ticket or cast-in-stone day off from work/wife/whatever.

Several of these dates will change to suit the needs of television, and the changes will take absolutely no account of the interests (or pockets) of ordinary supporters.

That’s why our supporters found themselves having to get to Southampton for a 5.15pm kickoff on a Monday evening in April.

It’s manipulation of the fixtures list at its most cyncical, and leaves decent fans with feelings of contempt for the big business stranglehold on our game. But since it’s not going to stop happening any time soon, be prepared……

* Picture: Infactah

Read more

Halford’s on his bike, coming our way

Tasmin Archer fans will just have to wait a little. Salut! Sunderland feels duty bound to extend a warm welcome to Greg Halford, Roy Keane’s first summer signing and one that fills the heart with hope.

He’s 22, stands 6ft 5in and cost our moneyed Irish friends £3m from Reading. But he will be remembered by many at the Stadium of Light for his excellent performance in Colchester’s colours against us last season.

As a right back, he fits a slot vacated by the return to Man Utd of Danny Simpson and represents a great start to the team strengthening we all knew was necessary if we are to re-establish ourselves in the Premiership.

There is room for improvement in most areas, but Keano is sensible to start at the back – though a glace at Halford’s record shows he is a useful goalcorer, too.

The rumour mill is working overtime – frankly I’d be disappointed otherwise – and we have been linked with any number of other players.

Read more